Check it connects to your sales channels, ask for its accuracy and on-time figures, confirm it can handle your peak, read the contract and minimums, visit the warehouse, and meet the people who would run your account.
Location matters too: a warehouse near most of your customers delivers faster and costs less to ship.
Ask for two client references and call them. Ask what went wrong and how it was fixed, because something always goes wrong eventually.
Get quotes from three or four, including us if we fit. A good 3PL should tell you when it isn’t the right one for you.